Middle Island Pizza - Middle Island, KY

Welcome to Middle Island Pizza

Providing Exceptional Service & Quality for Over 30 Years

It all started in 1968 at the age of 17 , our father came to America with part of his family, some were already here and some still yet had to make the journey. He worked hard to have a better life, one that he knew was possible but never promised. years later, he finally had worked hard enough and saved enough to open his first pizzeria. With our mother at his side, and a growing family, they worked tirelessly for 30 years to build a business and raise a family . 

 The D’Onofrio family is honored to offer you catering for any affair or occasion. Whether you’re planning a shower, engagement party, sweet sixteen, office lunch or just a family get together. We will custom design a menu for you. We can accommodate in-house dining or we can provide you with a staff at the location of your choice.

Classic Italian Catering

Celebrate Life's Moments in Middle Island

Our family is honored to offer you catering for any occasion, from baby showers to corporate events and holiday parties. Choose from favorites like Baked Ziti, Chicken Francese, Eggplant Rollatini, or Mini Cannoli Trays, all made with love and tradition. Whatever you choose, it surely will be a winning combo. Reach out today, and let us take care of the rest!

Order Authentic Italian Food

Available for Delivery and Pick‑Up in Middle Island

Ordering online is simple and convenient, just pick your favorites, from our Crispino Pie and Hawaiian Pizza to trays of Garlic Knots or a classic Calzone baked to order. Every dish is prepared with the same attention and care you'd expect when dining in.

Party and Group Reservations

Creating Memories Worth Sharing

Every private event deserves care, attention, and a touch of comfort that makes guests feel at ease. From small dinners to milestone celebrations, we help you create an experience that reflects your style and story. Enjoy classic recipes and the kind of service that lets you focus on what matters the most.

Book now a private party

Jobs

Be Part of Our Story

Join a team that values hard work, dedication, and a love for great food. At our restaurant, every role matters, and together we create an environment built on respect, teamwork, and passion for what we do every day.

Apply now for a job
previous slidenext slide

The buzz

Location

586 Middle Country Rd
Middle Island, KY
11953

Hours

Sun, Mon, Tue, Wed, Thur, Fri, Sat
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM